The cold rain falls here in State College, flutily trying to cleanse the Earth. Evil has gripped the US. It was on full display the other night during a televised speech to Congress.
Rainy days always make me reflective. Perhaps rain are the tears of God or the dead. Perhaps they are a metaphor for renewal and life, as water evaporates, rise, condenses, falls back to Earth just to eventually evaporate again.
Wow. Corny metaphors... and I'm not even drunk.
In any case, In the past week, people asked me questions that really gave me pause. I figure writing them down would help me think through and process my answers. You lucky people.
Recent pic
The first was asked to me by a co-worker the other day, then by a therapy student last night: What would healing look like for you?
This first came up during a discussion about Justice. My coworker (who is against carceral state) believes that punishment doesn't help the victim at all. My counter-point was "so the perpetrator just commits a crime, and gets away with it?" Their point was that these are two separate issues- that society cares more about punishment than restoring the victim. The coworker was once the victim of a hideous crime (I'm not at liberty to say what) while living in Hong Kong, and said that the first thing the authorities there did was to help them recover from the crime. (yes, the perp was caught and punished.) Hence the question.
My answer: Wow. I really have no idea. I've lost so much and have the scars to prove it. Move to a different house with Wife and daughter and live as a family again? (and drag Linda along as well.) The issue here is that if someone comforts me (like says "I'm proud of you), I don't believe them. It bounces off my armor and doesn't get through (just like compliments.) I've thought of this for a couple of days... am I beyond healing? I mean- there's no way to have my years restored to me. Apologies, while helpful, don't restore. The "plate is still broken" so to speak.
Of course, I could just let go of the past, and all the Pain. But that Pain defines me- drives me.
Without the experiences that caused the Pain (and other experiences) that make me who I am, for good or for ill. That Pain gave me my drive and passion for justice. Would justice on those who hurt me long ago bring me healing? Not now. Justice must be swift to be helpful. That said, there are some graves that it would me great pleasure to, ahem, defecate upon.
This is a question I need to really consider. A lot.
I thought of the second the other night while watching Casablanca. That's a movie about many things, with regret being a major theme. I thought about the losses I've endured- the many regrets I've piled up in my life. Then I asked myself: Is it worse to regret something you did or something you did not do?
I posted the question on facialbook and received some good answers.
My answer: Something I did NOT do. It's the hell of "what if." When I regret something I did, I at least tried and found an outcome. For example: I transitioned, and the following happened: blah blah. I maintain that those results are better than wondering where my life would've been had not transitioned, but still wanted to. If that makes sense. (I already know what the alternative to transition would've been: death.)
The third question was asked to me at a presentation I frequently do here at PSU: it's a brief LGBTQ 101, followed by the stories of the presenters, then a Q&A. Usually the audience are undergrads, as we (me and the other presenters) are invited to speak to classes by the professors. An F2M person (they told me) asked me the following: What is your favorite part of being a woman?
In my eleven years of presenting about transgender issues, no one has EVER asked me that. A question I get frequently is "What do you miss about being a man?" (I usually steal Jennifer Finney Boylan's answer to that: "Pockets.") Yet never the opposite. The student said they couldn't imagine wanting any part of being female. I get it- that's dysphoria.
The answer I eventually gave was the 'permission' to feel and express emotions. Guys really aren't allowed to do that lest they be accused of being "gay." (Masculinity is a rigid, narrow course.) Now, if I wish, I can cry, laugh, express all the emotions I wish. After all, there's no 'restrictions' on women for expressing emotions. Also, the estrogen allows me to feel more emotions. There are emotions I experience that I can't even name. (Did I install an emotion chip?)
In any case, all three are questions I need to keep considering. If nothing else, to take my mind off the hell on earth that MAGA has made the world.
Be well.